NHL GM's Rating

Select A Rating

NHL GM's Rating

Top 5 Gm's Back To Back

Top 5 GM's 3 Consecutives

Top 10 GM 1st Round Picks

Top 10 Most Consistent GMs

Top 15 GMs - Best 5th Round+ P...

Top 20 GMs - Best 2-4 Round Pi...

Top 25 GM (One Draft) Picks

Top 50 GM 1st Round Picks

Top 100 GM Picks (non 1st roun...

Rogatien Vachon FINAL

RATING 6.1

RANKING 36

Draft	Num	Rnd	Player	Pos	Drafted from...	GP	G	A	Pts	Score
ROUND 1
1987 Entry	4	1	Wayne McBean	D	Medicine Hat Tigers [WHL]	211	10	39	49	-2
1986 Supplemental	9	1	Bob Kudelski	C	Yale University [ECAC]	442	139	102	241	+1
1985 Entry	9	1	Craig Duncanson	L	Sudbury Wolves [OHL]	38	5	4	9	-2
1985 Entry	10	1	Dan Gratton	C	Oshawa Generals [OHL]	7	1	0	1	-2
1984 Entry	6	1	Craig Redmond	D	Canadian National Team [Intl]	191	16	68	84	-2
										ROUND 1 -7
ROUND 2+
1987 Entry	27	2	Mark Fitzpatrick	G	Medicine Hat Tigers [WHL]	329	0	12	12	+1
1991 Entry	81	4	Alexei Zhitnik	D	Kiev Sokol [Russia]	1085	96	375	471	+2
1988 Entry	70	4	Rob Blake	D	Bowling Green State University [CCHA]	1270	240	537	777	+3
1992 Entry	135	6	Rem Murray	L	Michigan State University [CCHA]	560	94	121	215	+1
1990 Entry	133	7	Robert Lang	C	Litvinov HC [Czech]	989	261	442	703	+2.5
1984 Entry	171	9	Luc Robitaille	L	Hull Olympiques [QMJHL]	1431	668	726	1394	+3.5
										ROUND 2+ 13

George McPhee

RATING 5.9

RANKING 37

Draft	Num	Rnd	Player	Pos	Drafted from...	GP	G	A	Pts	Score
ROUND 1
2012 Entry	11	1	Filip Forsberg	L	Leksands IF [Swe-1]	458	166	187	353	+2	1st in Points
2010 Entry	26	1	Evgeny Kuznetsov	C	Chelyabinsk Traktor [KHL]	479	120	269	389	+2	4th in Assists/6th in Points
2008 Entry	21	1	Anton Gustafsson	C	Frolunda Jrs (Sweden)					-3
2008 Entry	27	1	John Carlson	D	Indiana Ice [USHL]	757	105	373	478	+2	4th in Assists/5th in Points
2007 Entry	5	1	Karl Alzner	D	Calgary Hitmen [WHL]	686	20	110	130	-1
2006 Entry	4	1	Nicklas Backstrom	C	Brynas IF Gavle [SEL]	956	243	684	927	+2.5	1st in Assists/Points
2005 Entry	14	1	Sasha Pokulok	D	Cornell University [ECAC]					-3
2005 Entry	27	1	Joe Finley	D	Sioux Falls Stampede [USHL]	21	0	1	1	-1
2004 Entry	29	1	Mike Green	D	Saskatoon Blades [WHL]	880	150	351	501	+2	4th in Assists/6th in Points
2002 Entry	13	1	Alexander Semin	R	Cherepovets Jr. (Russia)	650	239	278	517	+2.5	3rd in Points
1999 Entry	7	1	Kris Beech	C	Calgary Hitmen [WHL]	198	25	42	67	-2
1997 Entry	9	1	Nick Boynton	D	Ottawa 67's [OHL]	605	34	110	144	-1
										ROUND 1 2
ROUND 2+
2009 Entry	55	2	Dmitri Orlov	D	Novokuznetsk Metallurg [KHL]	516	37	143	180	+1
2006 Entry	34	2	Michal Neuvirth	G	Sparta Jrs. (Czech Rep)	257	0	4	4	+1
2009 Entry	85	3	Cody Eakin	C	Swift Current Broncos [WHL]	586	103	134	237	+1
2008 Entry	93	4	Braden Holtby	G	Saskatoon Blades [WHL]	468	0	11	11	+2.5
2006 Entry	177	6	Mathieu Perreault	L	Acadie-Bathurst Titan [QMJHL]	627	130	195	325	+1.5
2001 Entry	221	7	Johnny Oduya	D	Victoriaville Tigres [QMJHL]	850	41	149	190	+1
										ROUND 2+ 8

Don Maloney

RATING 5.7

RANKING 38

Draft	Num	Rnd	Player	Pos	Drafted from...	GP	G	A	Pts	Score
ROUND 1
2012 Entry	27	1	Henrik Samuelsson	C	Edmonton Oil Kings [WHL]	3	0	0	0	-1
2010 Entry	13	1	Brandon Gormley	D	Moncton Wildcats [QMJHL]	58	2	3	5	-1
2010 Entry	27	1	Mark Visentin	G	Niagara IceDogs [OHL]	1	0	0	0	-1
2007 Entry	30	1	Nick Ross	D	Regina Pats [WHL]					-3
1993 Entry	23	1	Todd Bertuzzi	R	Guelph Storm [OHL]	1159	314	456	770	+2	3rd in Goals/4th in Points
										ROUND 1 -4
ROUND 2+
2014 Entry	58	2	Christian Dvorak	C	London Knights [OHL]	246	50	65	115	+1
1995 Entry	28	2	Jan Hlavac	L	Sparta Praha [Czech]	436	90	134	224	+1
1993 Entry	40	2	Bryan McCabe	D	Spokane Chiefs [WHL]	1135	145	383	528	+2
2008 Entry	69	3	Michael Stone	D	Calgary Hitmen [WHL]	472	31	93	124	+1
1994 Entry	63	3	Jason Strudwick	D	Kamloops Blazers [WHL]	674	13	42	55	+1
1994 Entry	90	4	Brad Lukowich	D	Kamloops Blazers [WHL]	658	23	90	113	+1
1993 Entry	118	5	Tommy Salo	G	Vasteras IK [SEL]	526	0	7	7	+1.5
1994 Entry	272	11	Dick Tarnstrom	D	AIK [SEL]	306	35	105	140	+1
										ROUND 2+ 9.5

Bob Pulford FINAL

RATING 5.3

RANKING 39

Draft	Num	Rnd	Player	Pos	Drafted from...	GP	G	A	Pts	Score
ROUND 1
2004 Entry	3	1	Cam Barker	D	Medicine Hat Tigers [WHL]	310	21	75	96	-2
2000 Entry	10	1	Mikhail Yakubov	C	Tolyatti-2	53	2	10	12	-2
2000 Entry	11	1	Pavel Vorobiev	R	Yaroslavl Torpedo [Russia]	57	10	15	25	-1
1997 Entry	16	1	Ty Jones	R	Spokane Chiefs [WHL]	14	0	0	0	-1
1995 Entry	19	1	Dmitri Nabokov	C	Krylja Sovetov [Russia]	55	11	13	24	-1
1993 Entry	24	1	Eric Lecompte	L	Hull Olympiques [QMJHL]					-3
1989 Entry	6	1	Adam Bennett	D	Sudbury Wolves [OHL]	69	3	8	11	-2
1988 Entry	8	1	Jeremy Roenick	C	Thayer Academy (Mass.)	1363	513	703	1216	+2	3RD in Goals/ Points
1987 Entry	8	1	Jimmy Waite	G	Chicoutimi Sagueneens [QMJHL]	106	0	1	1	-2
1983 Entry	18	1	Bruce Cassidy	D	Ottawa 67's [OHL]	36	4	13	17	-1
1982 Entry	7	1	Ken Yaremchuk	C	Portland Winter Hawks [WHL]	235	36	56	92	-2
										ROUND 1 -15
ROUND 2+
2004 Entry	32	2	Dave Bolland	C	London Knights [OHL]	433	85	123	208	+1
1983 Entry	39	2	Wayne Presley	R	Kitchener Rangers [OHL]	684	155	147	302	+1
1984 Entry	45	3	Trent Yawney	D	Saskatoon Blades [WHL]	593	27	102	129	+1
1983 Entry	59	3	Marc Bergevin	D	Chicoutimi Sagueneens [QMJHL]	1191	36	145	181	+2
1980 Entry	57	3	Troy Murray	C	St. Albert Saints [AJHL]	914	230	354	584	+2
1993 Entry	90	4	Eric Daze	L	Beauport Harfangs [QMJHL]	601	226	172	398	+2
1980 Entry	67	4	Carey Wilson	C	Dartmouth College [ECAC]	552	169	258	427	+2
1997 Entry	130	5	Kyle Calder	L	Regina Pats [WHL]	590	114	180	294	+1.5
1980 Entry	120	6	Steve Larmer	R	Niagara Falls Flyers [OHA]	1006	441	571	1012	+3
1979 Entry	112	6	Doug Crossman	D	Ottawa 67's [OHA]	914	105	359	464	+2
2004 Entry	214	7	Troy Brouwer	R	Moose Jaw Warriors [WHL]	851	182	181	363	+1
1984 Entry	132	7	Mike Stapleton	C	Cornwall Royals [OHL]	697	71	111	182	+1
1983 Entry	179	9	Brian Noonan	R	Archbishop Williams H.S. (Mass.)	629	116	159	275	+1.5
1983 Entry	199	10	Dominik Hasek	G	Pardubice HC [Czech]	735	0	19	19	+3.5
1978 Amateur	179	11	Darryl Sutter	C	Lethbridge Broncos [WCHL]	406	161	118	279	+2
										ROUND 2+ 26.5

Neil Smith FINAL

RATING 5.2

RANKING 40

Draft	Num	Rnd	Player	Pos	Drafted from...	GP	G	A	Pts	Score
ROUND 1
1999 Entry	4	1	Pavel Brendl	R	Calgary Hitmen [WHL]	78	11	11	22	-2
1999 Entry	9	1	Jamie Lundmark	C	Moose Jaw Warriors [WHL]	295	40	59	99	-2
1997 Entry	19	1	Stefan Cherneski	R	Brandon Wheat Kings [WHL]					-3
1996 Entry	22	1	Jeff Brown	D	Sarnia Sting [OHL]					-3
1992 Entry	24	1	Peter Ferraro	R	Waterloo Black Hawks [USHL]	92	9	15	24	-1
1991 Entry	15	1	Alexei Kovalev	R	Moscow Dynamo [Russia]	1316	430	599	1029	+2.5	1st in Goals/Points
1990 Entry	13	1	Michael Stewart	D	Michigan State University [CCHA]					-3
										ROUND 1 -11.5
ROUND 2+
1992 Entry	48	2	Mattias Norstrom	D	AIK [SEL]	903	18	147	165	+1.5
1990 Entry	34	2	Doug Weight	C	Lake Superior State University [CCHA]	1238	278	755	1033	+2.5
1995 Entry	91	4	Marc Savard	C	Oshawa Generals [OHL]	807	207	499	706	+2.5
1990 Entry	85	5	Sergei Zubov	D	CSKA Moscow [Russia]	1068	152	619	771	+2.5
2006 Entry	160	6	Andrew MacDonald	D	Moncton Wildcats [QMJHL]	586	28	133	161	+1
1997 Entry	136	6	Mike York	L	Michigan State University [CCHA]	579	127	195	322	+1.5
1993 Entry	164	7	Todd Marchant	C	Clarkson University [ECAC]	1195	186	312	498	+2
1994 Entry	234	9	Eric Boulton	L	Oshawa Generals [OHL]	654	31	48	79	+1
1994 Entry	286	11	Kim Johnsson	D	Malmo IF [SEL]	739	67	217	284	+1.5
1990 Entry	244	12	Sergei Nemchinov	L	Krylja Sovetov [Russia]	761	152	193	345	+2
										ROUND 2+ 18

Jim Rutherford

RATING 4.5

RANKING 41

Draft	Num	Rnd	Player	Pos	Drafted from...	GP	G	A	Pts	Score
ROUND 1
2010 Entry	7	1	Jeff Skinner	C	Kitchener Rangers [OHL]	720	258	207	465	+2	2nd in Goals
2009 Entry	27	1	Philippe Paradis	C	Shawinigan Cataractes [QMJHL]					-3
2005 Entry	3	1	Jack Johnson	D	U.S. Junior National Team [Intl]	937	70	232	302	-1
2002 Entry	25	1	Cam Ward	G	Red Deer Rebels [WHL]	701	1	12	13	+2.5	Excellent Goalie
2001 Entry	15	1	Igor Knyazev	D	Moscow Spartak [Russia]					-3
1998 Entry	11	1	Jeff Heerema	R	Sarnia Sting [OHL]	32	4	2	6	-1
1997 Entry	22	1	Nikos Tselios	D	Belleville Bulls [OHL]	2	0	0	0	-1
1995 Entry	13	1	Jean-Sebastien Giguere	G	Halifax Mooseheads [QMJHL]	596	0	7	7	+2	Excellent Goalie
										ROUND 1 -2.5
ROUND 2+
2011 Entry	42	2	Victor Rask	C	Leksands IF [Swe-1]	405	70	109	179	+1
2010 Entry	37	2	Justin Faulk	D	U.S. National Development Team [USHL]	628	90	184	274	+1
1998 Entry	71	3	Erik Cole	L	Clarkson University [ECAC]	892	265	267	532	+2
2012 Entry	120	4	Jaccob Slavin	D	Chicago Steel [USHL]	377	29	122	151	+1
2000 Entry	97	4	Niclas Wallin	D	Brynas IF Gavle [SEL]	614	21	58	79	+1
1995 Entry	87	4	Sami Kapanen	R	HIFK Helsinki [SM-liiga]	831	189	269	458	+1.5
2010 Entry	187	7	Frederik Andersen	G	Frederikshavn White Hawks [Denmark]	369	0	8	8	+2
1996 Entry	223	9	Craig Adams	R	Harvard University [ECAC]	951	55	105	160	+1
										ROUND 2+ 10.5

Ray Shero

RATING 3

RANKING 42

Draft	Num	Rnd	Player	Pos	Drafted from...	GP	G	A	Pts	Score
ROUND 1
2007 Entry	20	1	Angelo Esposito	C	Quebec Remparts [QMJHL]					-3
										ROUND 1 -3
ROUND 2+
2013 Entry	77	3	Jake Guentzel	L	Sioux City Musketeers [USHL]	243	98	102	200	+2
2012 Entry	83	3	Matt Murray	G	Soo Greyhounds [OHL]	199	0	4	4	+1.5
2010 Entry	80	3	Bryan Rust	R	U.S. National Development Team [USHL]	308	78	92	170	+1
2007 Entry	141	5	Jake Muzzin	D	Soo Greyhounds [OHL]	579	62	190	252	+1.5
										ROUND 2+ 6

Dale Tallon

RATING 1.7

RANKING 43

Draft	Num	Rnd	Player	Pos	Drafted from...	GP	G	A	Pts	Score
ROUND 1
2010 Entry	25	1	Quinton Howden	C	Moose Jaw Warriors [WHL]	97	10	7	17	-1
2008 Entry	11	1	Kyle Beach	L	Everett Silvertips [WHL]					-1
2005 Entry	7	1	Jack Skille	R	U.S. Junior National Team [Intl]	368	43	41	84	-2
										ROUND 1 -4
ROUND 2+
2011 Entry	64	3	Vincent Trocheck	C	Saginaw Spirit [OHL]	427	112	172	284	+1.5
2010 Entry	99	4	Joonas Donskoi	R	Karpat [SM-liiga]	348	61	94	155	+1
2005 Entry	108	4	Niklas Hjalmarsson	D	HV71 Jonkoping [SEL]	780	25	142	167	+1
2010 Entry	123	5	Zach Hyman	C	Hamilton Red Wings [OJHL]	302	71	81	152	+1.5
2009 Entry	149	5	Marcus Kruger	C	Djurgarden Jrs. (Sweden)	520	38	85	123	+1
										ROUND 2+ 6

Mike Milbury FINAL

RATING 1.1

RANKING 44

Draft	Num	Rnd	Player	Pos	Drafted from...	GP	G	A	Pts	Score
ROUND 1
2005 Entry	15	1	Ryan O'Marra	C	Erie Otters [OHL]	33	1	6	7	-1
2000 Entry	1	1	Rick DiPietro	G	Boston University [H-East]	318	0	19	19	-2
2000 Entry	5	1	Raffi Torres	L	Brampton Battalion [OHL]	635	137	123	260	-1
1999 Entry	10	1	Branislav Mezei	D	Belleville Bulls [OHL]	240	5	19	24	-1
1999 Entry	28	1	Kristian Kudroc	D	Michalovce (Slovakia)	26	2	2	4	-1
1998 Entry	9	1	Mike Rupp	L	Erie Otters [OHL]	609	54	45	99	-1
										ROUND 1 -7
ROUND 2+
2004 Entry	47	2	Blake Comeau	L	Kelowna Rockets [WHL]	852	136	183	319	+1.5
2002 Entry	87	3	Frans Nielsen	C	Malmo IF [SEL]	896	166	301	467	+2
1996 Entry	56	3	Zdeno Chara	D	Trencin Dukla [Slovak]	1553	205	451	656	+2.5
2004 Entry	227	7	Chris Campoli	D	Erie Otters [OHL]	440	35	111	146	+1
1999 Entry	228	8	Radek Martinek	D	Ceske Budejovice HC [Czech]	486	25	85	110	+1
										ROUND 2+ 8

Brian Burke

RATING -1.9

RANKING 45

Draft	Num	Rnd	Player	Pos	Drafted from...	GP	G	A	Pts	Score
ROUND 1
2011 Entry	22	1	Tyler Biggs	R	U.S. National Development Team [USHL]					-3
2011 Entry	25	1	Stuart Percy	D	Mississauga St. Michael's Majors [OHL]	12	0	3	3	-1
2007 Entry	19	1	Logan MacMillan	C	Halifax Mooseheads [QMJHL]					-3
2006 Entry	19	1	Mark Mitera	D	U. of Michigan [CCHA]					-3
2001 Entry	16	1	R.J. Umberger	C	Ohio State University [CCHA]	779	180	212	392	+2	4th in Goals
2000 Entry	23	1	Nathan Smith	C	Swift Current Broncos [WHL]	26	0	0	0	-1
1998 Entry	4	1	Bryan Allen	D	Oshawa Generals [OHL]	721	29	107	136	-2
1992 Entry	9	1	Robert Petrovicky	C	Trencin Dukla [Czech.]	208	27	38	65	-2
										ROUND 1 -13
ROUND 2+
2008 Entry	43	2	Justin Schultz	D	Westside Warriors [BCHL]	482	50	164	214	+1.5
1992 Entry	47	2	Andrei Nikolishin	C	Moscow Dynamo [Russia]	628	93	187	280	+1
1998 Entry	68	3	Jarkko Ruutu	L	HIFK Helsinki [SM-liiga]	652	58	84	142	+1
1993 Entry	72	3	Marek Malik	D	Vitkovice HC [Czech]	691	33	135	168	+1.5
2001 Entry	151	5	Kevin Bieksa	D	Bowling Green State University [CCHA]	808	63	215	278	+1.5
1993 Entry	115	5	Nolan Pratt	D	Portland Winter Hawks [WHL]	592	9	56	65	+1
2012 Entry	156	6	Connor Brown	R	Erie Otters [OHL]	324	59	83	142	+1
1993 Entry	188	8	Manny Legace	G	Niagara Falls Thunder [OHL]	365	0	9	9	+2
										ROUND 2+ 10.5